How to Choose the Perfect Underlying Assets
for Consistent Income and Peace of Mind
By now, you understand the mechanics of the Wheel Strategy—the interplay of cash-secured puts and covered calls, and how the cycle generates repeatable income. But the success of the wheel doesn't hinge on clever option timing or squeezing extra pennies of premium. It lives and dies by what you choose to trade.
The asset you sell options on is your foundation. It determines your downside risk, the emotional calm you can maintain during dips, and the sustainability of your returns. The best wheel traders aren't chasing the highest yields—they're curating the right stocks, ETFs, and occasionally, alternative assets that fit their personality, time horizon, and conviction.
This chapter teaches you how to find those assets: how to screen for fundamentally strong companies, ETFs that behave predictably, and even how to cautiously consider commodities or crypto assets that can work within the wheel framework. We'll cover filters, metrics, and mental models that keep your portfolio both resilient and rewarding.
The golden rule of the wheel is simple:
"Only sell puts on assets you'd be happy to own."
When you sell a cash-secured put, you're making a conditional promise: "If this stock falls to my strike price, I'll buy it." That means you must be comfortable buying it. If your only motivation is high premium and not the quality of the business, you're gambling, not investing.
Ask yourself before selling any put:
If the answer is "yes," you've found a suitable wheel candidate. If you hesitate, it's not worth the anxiety.
The perfect wheel stock has a few consistent traits:
A. Liquid Options Market
Liquidity means tight bid-ask spreads, consistent volume, and multiple expirations. You want options chains where you can easily enter and exit positions without losing money to slippage.
Checklist:
Examples:
Apple (AAPL), Microsoft (MSFT), AMD, SPY, QQQ, Ford (F), JPM, KO, XOM.
B. Moderate Volatility (Not Too Hot, Not Too Cold)
Volatility is the lifeblood of option premiums—but too much can burn you. You want medium volatility: enough to earn decent premiums, but not so high that the stock whipsaws 10% in a week.
C. Stable, Fundamentally Sound Companies
If assigned, you're now a shareholder. That means fundamentals matter. The company should be profitable or on a clear path there. Look for:
Example:
Selling puts on a company like PepsiCo (PEP) is safer than on a speculative biotech that could halve overnight on bad trial data.
D. Affordable Share Price
Because each option contract controls 100 shares, a $300 stock requires $30,000 per contract to collateralize. That's heavy. For most retail traders, the sweet spot is between $20 and $100 per share—cheap enough to diversify, but liquid enough for option markets.
Examples:
Ford (F), Intel (INTC), Palantir (PLTR), Pfizer (PFE), Coca-Cola (KO), Bank of America (BAC).
Here's a practical way to build your watchlist.
Step 1: Start with Option Liquidity
Use an options screener (such as Thinkorswim, Interactive Brokers, or Barchart.com) to filter:
Step 2: Filter by Fundamental Quality
Narrow further using stock screeners like Finviz or Yahoo Finance:
Step 3: Check Volatility
Look at the stock's IV Rank or Historical Volatility:
Step 4: Test the Chart (Not for Prediction, But Comfort)
Glance at a 1-year daily chart:
Your goal isn't technical perfection—it's emotional comfort. If you can stomach holding this stock during normal pullbacks, you can wheel it.
Step 5: Build a Shortlist
Aim for 8–15 names you like, spanning different sectors. Example breakdown:
ETFs are ideal wheel candidates for many traders, especially beginners. They diversify your risk automatically and reduce company-specific blowups.
Why ETFs Work for the Wheel
Top ETF Wheel Picks
| ETF | Description | Why It's Good |
|---|---|---|
| SPY | S&P 500 | Extremely liquid, moderate premiums, steady growth |
| QQQ | Nasdaq 100 | Higher volatility, better premiums |
| DIA | Dow Jones | Low volatility, great for conservative income |
| IWM | Russell 2000 | Smaller caps, high premium potential |
| VTI | Total Market | Balanced exposure, good for long-term holding |
| XLF | Financials | Sector-focused wheel candidate |
| XLE | Energy | Great when oil cycles are stable |
ETFs are ideal for hands-off investors who still want monthly income without worrying about individual earnings reports.
The wheel can, in theory, work on any asset with an options market—commodities, metals, or even crypto. But caution and volatility management are essential.
Commodities
ETFs like GLD (gold), SLV (silver), or USO (oil) have liquid options and are tied to real-world assets.
Pros:
Cons:
Crypto (Bitcoin and Ethereum)
In recent years, Bitcoin ETFs and crypto exchanges have introduced options products (e.g., BITO, ETHX, CME BTC options).
Pros:
Cons:
Verdict:
Commodities and crypto can supplement your wheel portfolio after you've mastered equities. Use small size and assume higher variance in outcomes.
Every asset you pick should pass this question:
"If I get assigned and the price drops 20%, would I be comfortable holding for a year?"
If your answer is no—don't wheel it. The wheel rewards patience and capital endurance. The only way to win over time is to hold assets that recover and compound.
Ideal wheel stocks are "sleep-at-night" names—companies or funds that you can confidently own even if assignment turns into a six-month hold.
Avoid loading your entire wheel into one sector. Tech might pay higher premiums, but diversification ensures that one earnings miss doesn't derail your entire income stream.
Example Allocation:
This distribution balances income generation and risk. When one sector underperforms, others often compensate.
Fundamentally sound companies tend to:
Remember: when the market panics, low-quality names evaporate. Blue-chip stocks stay liquid, allowing you to roll positions and maintain income.
If you focus on quality first, your wheel remains intact during corrections.
Let's create a sample watchlist together.
| Ticker | Sector | Price | IV Rank | Dividend | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AAPL | Tech | $180 | 35% | 0.5% | Blue-chip stability, weekly options |
| KO | Staples | $56 | 40% | 3.0% | Defensive, steady premiums |
| JPM | Financial | $150 | 38% | 2.8% | Resilient bank, great liquidity |
| XLE | Energy ETF | $88 | 45% | 3.5% | Oil volatility provides premium |
| IWM | Index ETF | $200 | 42% | 1.5% | Broad small-cap exposure |
| PFE | Healthcare | $32 | 48% | 4.5% | Cheap, defensive sector |
| PLTR | Tech | $20 | 55% | 0% | Growth + juicy premiums |
| SLV | Commodity | $24 | 50% | 0% | Precious metal hedge |
| SOFI | Fintech | $7 | 60% | 0% | High premium speculative wheel |
| SPY | Index ETF | $450 | 33% | 1.3% | Diversified core holding |
Start small—perhaps with SPY and KO—to get comfortable, then add riskier plays gradually as your confidence and account grow.
Here are a few helpful tools to identify and evaluate potential wheel assets:
You don't need all of them. The goal is to develop intuition—seeing which names consistently produce healthy, predictable premiums.
Not every stock deserves your wheel capital. Avoid:
Remember: The wheel is not a lottery—it's a rental business. You're renting your capital for premium income. You want reliable tenants.
A well-constructed wheel portfolio feels boring.
If your positions cause anxiety, you've chosen the wrong assets. The best wheel traders build portfolios that align with their temperament, not their greed.
The essence of good wheel stock selection is this:
You trade calmness for consistency.
You sacrifice excitement for durability.
You aim to win small—but win always.
The Wheel thrives on quality. Choosing the right underlying assets means balancing fundamentals, volatility, liquidity, and your own emotional tolerance.
When you curate your assets carefully, the wheel stops being a trade—it becomes a business. You'll collect income, sleep well, and thrive through market cycles.
End of Chapter 4